... in response to Just to liven things up, posted by philb on Feb 16, 2002That is a good question. That is one of the mysteries that is really beyond man's understanding. The Bible clearly teaches that even though receiving God's grace is a personal free will decision, even before the creation of the world God predestined us to believe in Him.
This theological mystery, which seems to be paradoxical to those not well versed in the whole Scripture, led to some really big debates throughout history, particularly during the Reformation era. Luther, Calvin, Zwingli, Knox and Erasmus all had a thing or two to say about it. The subject was debated in written exchanges by these and many others during that period, and by many since.
Suffice to say that the extreme Calvinist view of absolute predestination, which would necessarily negate free will, has been virtually universally rejected as contradictory of the whole Scripture. I have dozens of Presbyterian friends and none of them, nor their preachers, subscribe to it.
The majority view is that God has predestined all of us to receive His Son, but he has left us with a free will to accept or reject. So everyone has been elected. But not everyone will accept the office. Given the fact that it is free, it is truly sad some decline what we could never earn and certainly do not deserve.
Regards,
WmGo